November 6, 2026 | 4 minute read
Governmentality
by
Summary
In this text (a transcription of a lecture), the author questions the idea of governmentality in the state. He argues a historic shift from a state of justice, one tied to the development of an art of government (and emerging from a question of the behavior of a ruler), to an administrative state related to regulation of items (including subjects and land), to a governmental state emerging from, and aimed at, population growth. This corresponds to a growth and then decline of the role of family as a parallel unit of governance.
The author begins with a question of a ruler, referencing the discussion of the appropriate conduct of a prince; this is a question of how a ruler should behave and what conduct is becoming and appropriate. Machiavelli’s work is described as an introduction of an “art of government”, an attempt to discern an internal, independent logic of governing. Over time, this shifts: one in power works to protect the “items” they rule over, of which people—subjects—represent one piece of a larger whole; this whole also includes territory. The author argues that “schematically, one can say that Machiavelli’s The Prince… is essentially a treatise about the prince’s ability to keep his principality” (90). This can be accomplished with an art of governance.
In working to define an art of governance, the author expands a conversation from a governance of subjects to governance of a household (as well as governance in education, and so-on). He argues that “there are three fundamental types of government, each of which relates to a particular science of discipline: the art of self-government, connected with morality; the act of properly governing a family, which belongs to economy; and finally, the science of ruling the state, which concerns politics” (91). A hierarchical line of power is established, where a governor of a state must learn to govern themselves in relationship to their goods (considered as inclusive of territory and subjects). They must simultaneously work to police the family through the introduction of economy, by which a family head can then govern their family. One parallels the other; “to govern a state will therefore mean to apply economy, to set up an economy at the level of the entire state, which means exercising towards its inhabitants, and the wealth and behavior of each and all, a form of surveillance and control as attentive as the head of a family over his household and his goods” (92). Surveillance and control are in support of successful governance—management—of items that are owned, and “government is the right disposition of things” (93). This is a form of management both at a level of the state and in the family, dealing with economy and also with unforeseen events and circumstances that require organization and action, and “to govern, then, means to govern things” (94).
The author argues that government is not concerned with laws. Instead, it is of disposition and arrangement: it is about “employing tactics rather than laws, and even of using laws themselves as tactics—to arrange things in such a way that, through a certain number of means, such and such ends may be achieved” (95). The relationship is between the things that are managed and the “pursuit of the perfection and intensification of the processes which it directs” (95); governance is a pursuit of an internal “rightness” and order. Wisdom is the positive encouragement that acts as a mechanism for this disposing, and is thought of as “the knowledge of things, of the objectives that can and should be attained, and the disposition of things required to reach them” (96).
Population growth then provokes a shift from a pursuit of an internal rightness or an art of governance towards disposition, to one of a goal in and of itself—“population comes to appear above all else as the ultimate end of government… government has as its purpose not the act of government itself, but the welfare of the population” (100). Governance at scale requires a tempered, scientific approach, and “the transition that takes place in the eighteenth century from an art of government to a political science, from a regime dominated by structures of sovereignty to one ruled by techniques of government, turns on the theme of population and hence also on the birth of political economy” (101). This science, like all science, requires discipline, and operates at a scale of the aggregate.
The author concludes by emphasizing his exploration as one of a history of governmentality, which he defines in three ways. One is the creation of the procedures, calculations, and tactics that target a population. A second is the steadily increasing importance and role of this power over population. A third is the way in which the “administrative state… gradually becomes ‘governmentalized’” (103).
More concisely, this is a shift from a state of justice focused on a set of comportments (art) rather than divine rights, to an administrative state focused on territoriality, to a state of government defined in terms of growth and, therefore, control of population (both people and territory).
