November 14, 2026 | 3 minute read
Justifying Work: Occupational Rhetorics as Resources in Restaurant Kitchens
by
Critical Analysis
In this text, the author argues that occupations are related to identity (“meaningful work identities”, 90) and there is a “fitting” that occurs through occupation rhetoric. The rhetorics—the stories that we tell about ourselves and our work—“provide a structure by which they define their consequence” and serve to address the question of “what kind of person am I?” The core of the author’s argument is that “the choice of an occupational rhetoric solves identity problems for the worker” (92) and that different rhetorical strategies are used at different times by the same worker to evoke different ideas and images of self.
Using the world of cooks and restaurants as an example, the author notes that “a range of rhetorics is particularly evident in these occupations in which the public perception of the status and meaning of work is ambiguous and in those occupations that are responsible for a widely diverse set of tasks” (93). The different ways of explaining oneself are described as a “rhetorical ‘toolkit” from which to draw” (95) and are often made by way of analogy. The different arguments are made at various occasions, and include rhetorics of professionalism, art, business, and labor. Workers deploy different ways of discussing and framing themselves when the need is most appropriate.
At the heart of the author’s argument of occupational rhetorics is that people “use a range of occupational rhetorics as resources to provide a sense of self-worth” (111). The use of different strategies is variable, and the different rhetorics are used to both associate oneself with a particular area of work, and to distance oneself from another, when appropriate. This occurs through “deeds, words and thoughts” and “workers depend on images of their work and its characteristics to create occupational identity”—“in practice, workers use images and typifications when and if they seem appropriate: [this is] the bricolage of identity work” (111-112).
It’s plausible that students in design education are learning the different rhetorical devices and strategies they can deploy, and as they learn them, they are practicing: they try on different ways of discussing themselves and their work in a manner that suits their emerging designerly identity. Vulnerability, safety and trauma are analogous to physical harm and victimization, and students work with this language when useful to establish themselves as brave survivors. Language of hard, long hours worked transforms the process of design to labor, and allows for an identity presentation as a steadfast, “blue collar” worker with grit (and potentially serving to distance oneself from “management” and form associations with “fellow workers”). Using entrepreneurial references translates creativity into a form of self-preservation; this particular form of identity positioning is, I argue, governed rather than selected: both external and internal forces urge this presentation of self at the expense of others.
While Fine presents the deployment of these strategies as somewhat purposeful and as a mature decision being made, it’s likely that students are leveraging ways of speaking based on the discourse of studio, and are emulating rather than selecting. An occupational rhetoric of bravery is emerging from what they see and hear described, and even assigned, by their professors (and likely throughout their previous educational experiences); presenting oneself as a judge emerges from the language used during the experience of critique. The trying-on is tentative and the deployment is not reasoned. It is being learned alongside process, method and skill.
